The French Revolution: How a Bankrupt Kingdom Became a Nation in Arms
Sumeru & Seed Editorial BoardIn ten years France abolished feudalism, executed its king, fought most of Europe and invented the mass citizen army. The Revolution of 1789 did not only change France: it changed what a state could ask of its people — and what an army could be.
In the spring of 1789 France was the largest and richest kingdom in western Europe, with some twenty-eight million people. It was also unable to pay its debts. The treasury had been emptied by a century of wars — most recently the one that freed the American colonies — and the crown could not tax the privileged orders, the nobility and the Church, without their consent. To get it, Louis XVI summoned a body that had not met since 1614: the Estates-General.1
1789
The Estates met at Versailles on 5 May. Within six weeks the deputies of the Third Estate — the commoners — had declared themselves the National Assembly and sworn, in an indoor tennis court on 20 June, not to disband until France had a constitution. When the king gathered troops, Paris rose. On 14 July a crowd looking for gunpowder stormed the Bastille, the royal fortress-prison in the east of the city.
Events then moved faster than anyone had planned. On the night of 4 August the Assembly abolished feudal dues and privileges. On 26 August it adopted the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen: "Men are born and remain free and equal in rights." In October a march of market women brought the royal family from Versailles to Paris, where it remained, half ruler and half hostage.
The fall of the king
A constitutional monarchy might have lasted if the king had accepted it. In June 1791 he tried to flee the country and was stopped at Varennes. Trust did not recover. In April 1792 France declared war on Austria; Prussia joined Austria, the campaign began badly, and Parisians concluded they were being betrayed from within. On 10 August 1792 the Tuileries palace was stormed and the monarchy fell.
Six weeks later, on 20 September, an army of regulars and volunteers stood its ground under Prussian cannon fire at Valmy, and the invaders withdrew. The poet Goethe, who was there with the Prussian army, later claimed to have told his companions that a new era of world history began that day.2 The Republic was proclaimed in Paris the next morning. Louis XVI was tried and guillotined on 21 January 1793.
Terror and the nation in arms
By the summer of 1793 the Republic was at war with Austria, Prussia, Britain, Spain and the Dutch, and with rebels of its own in the Vendée and the great provincial cities. Its answer was the most radical government Europe had seen. The Committee of Public Safety, in which Maximilien Robespierre became the leading voice, ruled by emergency decree. Revolutionary courts sent some seventeen thousand people to the guillotine, and many more died in prison or in the civil war in the west.3
The same government created a new kind of army. The decree of 23 August 1793 — the levée en masse — declared every Frenchman permanently at the disposal of the armies: the young to fight, married men to forge arms, women to make tents and serve in hospitals. Within a year France had some three-quarters of a million men under arms. Lazare Carnot, the engineer officer who organised them, merged the old regiments with the volunteers and promoted on merit. Men who had been privates and sergeants in the king's army were generals within a few years: Jourdan, Hoche, Masséna, Ney, Murat. Too numerous to supply from depots, these armies lived off the land and moved fast; too raw to manoeuvre in long lines, they attacked in columns behind clouds of skirmishers. The kings of Europe, whose soldiers were costly and hard to replace, had no answer.
From Thermidor to Bonaparte
Victory removed the excuse for terror. On 27 July 1794 — 9 Thermidor in the new calendar — the Convention turned on Robespierre, and he was executed the next day. The five-man Directory that governed from 1795 was corrupt and unloved, and came to depend on its generals to win abroad and to keep order at home. The most successful of them, back from campaigns in Italy and Egypt, was a Corsican artillery officer of thirty. On 9–10 November 1799 — 18 Brumaire — Napoleon Bonaparte overthrew the Directory and made himself First Consul.
The Revolution had promised liberty and ended with a general. But its other work lasted: equality before the law, careers open to talent, the citizen who owes service to the nation — and the mass army, which Napoleon inherited and led to Vienna, Berlin and Moscow.
Notes
- William Doyle, The Oxford History of the French Revolution (3rd ed., 2018), chs. 3–4. ↩
- Goethe, Campaign in France (1822) — written thirty years after the event, so the famous remark may owe something to hindsight. ↩
- The figure for death sentences is Donald Greer's (The Incidence of the Terror, 1935), still generally used; estimates of all deaths, including the Vendée, are far higher. ↩
Further Reading
- William Doyle, The Oxford History of the French Revolution (3rd ed., Oxford, 2018).
- Simon Schama, Citizens: A Chronicle of the French Revolution (1989).
- T. C. W. Blanning, The French Revolutionary Wars, 1787–1802 (1996).
- Georges Lefebvre, The Coming of the French Revolution (1939; Eng. trans. 1947).
